navigate: home: magazine: fall 2003: article

Confronting Terrorism
Underwater sensor system could protect reservoirs, drinking water

By A’ndrea Elyse Messer

underwater sensor network
This is an illustration of how the underwater sensor network developed by Penn State engineers could be deployed in a body of water to monitor changes caused by pollutants, contaminants or chemicals introduced by terrorists.
Illustration and photo by Craig Grimes—Penn State





underwater sensor node
These are the components of the underwater sensor node, which is four inches in diameter, developed by Penn State engineers to monitor changes in water quality.

  A sensor system that can autonomously, continuously and in real-time monitor streams, lakes, ocean bays and other bodies of liquid may help solve problems for environmentalists, manufacturers and those in charge of homeland security, according to Penn State engineers.

  “The importance of developing a network sensor technology for operation in liquid environments has recently been highlighted in reports detailing the chemical slurry of antibiotics, estrogen-type hormones, insecticides, nicotine and other chemicals in the rivers of industrialized countries,” Dr. Craig A. Grimes, associate professor of electrical engineering and materials science and engineering, said. “However, analysis is still done by physically collecting samples and analyzing them back in the laboratory.”

  Monitoring of rivers downstream from sewage treatment plants, large city water supplies or the composition of a local pond must all be done by hand. This expensive, time-consuming and sometimes dangerous practice is always time delayed and may miss short duration episodes of pollution or contaminants. Continuous, in-place monitoring would be the easiest, timeliest and least expensive way to track changes in bodies of water.

  However, underwater monitoring is hampered, because water interferes with the radio transfer of information, the most common method used to transfer information in the air. The researchers, who include Grimes; Xiping Yang, William R. Dreschel, Kefeng Zeng and Casey S. Mungle, electrical engineering graduate students, Penn State; and Keat G. Ong at SenTech Corporation, State College, Pa., looked at a hierarchical, acoustic method to transfer the information from the sensors to the person monitoring the water.

  The researchers are looking at systems that can monitor temperature, salinity, acidity and specific chemicals. Some of the same researchers, in collaboration with Dr. Michael Pishko, associate professor of chemical engineering and material science at Penn State, are working on an inexpensive, disposable sensor for ricin, the highly poisonous protein found in castor beans and thought to be a potential terrorism agent. Sensors also exist for other harmful chemicals.

  In the aqueous sensor network system, an uplink node floats on the water’s surface and transfers the aqueous network data from the water to the air, where it is received by the command computer.

  Beneath the surface, layers of nodes/sensors monitor the water and pass the information along to the uplink. Sending a message from the farthest node direct to the uplink underwater is not possible, because of the way water decreases the strength of the acoustic signal, so the researchers use a node-to-node multihop information transfer system.

  “Node-to-node communication enables wide-area coverage using modest node power levels making practical long-term monitoring,” Grimes reported in a paper in the journal Sensors.

  After the network of nodes is deployed, floating anchored in place in the water, the system must set up an identification tree. The uplink node broadcasts a signal containing its identity. Every node that receives that broadcast marks the uplink node as its parent node. These nodes then broadcast a signal. Every node that receives that signal, and has not yet identified a parent node, will record the signaling node as its parent and then broadcast to even more distant nodes. A cascade of parent nodes eventually covers the entire system.

  Periodically, the network sends data through the system. Each node sends its sensor data to its parent node. That node sends the received data and its own data to its parent node until all the data are received by the uplink node, which converts the signal from acoustic to radio frequency and sends the information through the air to the command, or central, computer for display and evaluation.

  The host node stores the sensor data from all the nodes in its memory preserving the identity of the node that produced the data, so that water-monitoring personnel can track unusual readings or contaminants to their source location.

  The researchers designed the nodes so that the chemical sensors are immersed in water separate from the communication electronics, making it easy to change the sensors on the nodes without having to alter the signaling network.

  The National Science Foundation supported this work.

Top of Page
Previous Article Next Article
Table of Contents
Search Outreach News
Outreach Magazine Homepage
Outreach News Homepage

HOMELAND SECURITY BRIEF | Air systems

  Penn State engineers have developed a terrorist-resistant air conditioning concept they estimate costs less to install in new construction, is more energy efficient and is cheaper to operate than the current industry standard.

  Dr. Stanley A. Mumma, professor of architectural engineering and developer of the concept, said, “Currently, if an anthrax-laden letter is opened in an office, a standard forced-air and cooling system can carry the airborne spores to other locations in the building. Forced-air systems can also expose occupants throughout a building to odors and cold viruses or contribute to ‘sick building’ problems.”

  The new approach, called a Dedicated Outdoor Air System, decouples the process of supplying fresh air to a building’s occupants from the cooling and heating functions of the air conditioning system. Instead, it pairs an independent fresh air supply with “radiant cooling panels,” which use cool circulating water and can be installed as part of a building’s fire sprinkler system.

  Mumma explained that the approach does not use recirculated air—in conventional all-air systems, there is a nearly 80-percent carryover of recirculated air. Consequently, noxious agents released inside are diluted from each space, instead of being transported to other parts of the building by the air conditioning system. He estimates his approach will save $2 per square foot in new construction and that operating costs could be less than 60 to 70 percent of the cost of all-air systems.